The Double-Blind Of The Therapeutic

In The Triumph of the Therapeutic, Rieff describes modern society (the book was written in 1966) as completely different from the past. Previously, society was marked by “religious man” — and then, many centuries later, by “economic man”, and now, in the current stage, by “psychological man.”

And this new type of individual differs from ancestors in the way he creates meaning in his life. Whereas the older generations sought meaning from without, by burdening themselves with cultural traditions and economic aspirations, psychological man is mainly interested in maintaining a balanced mindset, he seeks meaning from within. A principal feature of psychological man is his indifference.

No longer the Saint, but the instinctual Everyman, twisting his neck uncomfortably inside the starched collar of culture, is the communal ideal, to whom men offer tacit prayers for deliverance from their inherited renunciations. Freud sought only to soften the collar; others, using bits and pieces of his genius, would like to take it off. Rieff, The Triumph of the Therapeutic

A society is made up of controls and releases. A cultural revolution, such as the one we are experiencing, occurs when the releases overwhelm the system of controls. The rise of Christianity was an example of such a revolution.

Near the end of the 19th century, Western culture became more remissive (a sign of an imminent cultural revolution). But unlike previous revolutions, the new culture does not have a new set of commitments.

Western culture is changing already into a symbol system unprecedented in its plasticity and absorptive capacity. Nothing much can opposite it really, and it welcomes all criticism, for, in a sense, it stands for nothing. Rieff, The Triumph of the Therapeutic

This vacuum that was created in a post-religious society was then filled by Freud and psychoanalysis. In short, Freud thought that psychological problems resulted from a triangular conflict between the id, ego, and superego. The old culture solved this tension by influencing the super-ego and crushing the id. The new culture, since it requires nothing from the individual, relaxes pressure on the superego, and allows the individual to be free.

Culture is another name for a design of motives directing the self outward, toward those communal purposes in which alone the self can be realized and satisfied. Rieff, The Triumph of the Therapeutic

But the cost of gaining freedom was the loss of meaning. A culture of commitments offers a consolation for the misery of living, because binding social commitments, while painful on many, holds out the promise of salvation. Christian culture offered its adherents a religious answer. Marxist culture offered its adherents an economic answer (the workers’ paradise). The psychological culture offers no mechanism for salvation, since it is individualistic. This marks the impoverishment of Western culture, according to Rieff.

While the old culture cured man’s psychological needs by giving him a communal purpose, the new culture encourages self-absorption and minimal group commitment.

Blinding loyalties are taboo. Psychological man stands for nothing, in congruence with Freud’s psychology of analysis and detachment.

Analysis impels the individual to understand but not to judge. And since there is a hierarchy between our competing instincts, we must give expression to all. The ultimate purpose is to prevent the negotiations from breaking down. That is, if you are conflicted between what your conscience tells you to do, and what you feel like doing — the solution would be to find a compromise. This is in contrast to the process of demonizing some impulses while glorifying others.

Freud thought that the person who questioned the meaning and value of life was sick, since objectively, neither exist. To the person who accepts Freud’s account, analysis appears rational, saving the individual from the pointless bustle which animated the lives of his ancestors.

The old answers to the deepest questions of life are no longer valid.

Thus, Freud created a major change in Western society.

His ideas were the anti-creed for those who thought of themselves as post-religious. But Freud refused to tell them what to pursue. He was only interested in giving them the tools to structure their inner life, even if the newly discovered structure is more imprisoning than what came before.

Freud proposed sublimation as the antidote to a meaning crisis — that is, to seek redemption through art. Here, Rieff quotes Harry Sullivan, a sage among psychologists, who said, “If you tell people how they can sublimate, they can’t sublimate.” The dynamics of culture are in the unwitting parts of it.

Originally published at http://unearnedwisdom.com.

I write about the best quality ideas that I have discovered

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store